Source Standards
The evidence hierarchy and citation rules used for Valkala devotional pages.
Last updated: 15 October 2026
How we check
- Old printed editions. Wherever we can, a prayer is taken from a scan of an old printed book that is now in the public domain, such as the Brihat Stotra Ratnakara printed in Bombay in 1912. Where a page follows a later printing, a digital text or a collection instead, it names that source.
- Page by page. Every verse is read against the page image itself, not against machine-read text, and the scan pages are recorded. The line under each prayer title names that edition and its pages, and “See the scan” opens it.
- Comparing editions. Where a second edition exists we compare the two word by word. When they differ we print one reading and record the other: which edition has it and why we chose ours. Look for “Variant reading” beside the verse.
- Meanings in three languages. We write our own meanings, kept close to the words, in English and, on almost every page, in Hindi and Hinglish (Hindi in Roman letters). We do not copy modern translations.
What the line under the title means. “Checked against” means the text was taken from, or corrected to, that source. “Compared with” marks an older, commonly sung version that was compared with the source but not taken from it. “Original retelling based on” means a katha told in our own words from the edition named. No page has been reviewed by an outside scholar, and every page says so.
Source hierarchy
- Primary textual sources: identified scripture, hymn, or edition, including mandala, sukta, chapter, or verse numbers where available.
- Institutional and scholarly references: universities, public cultural institutions, established text archives, critical editions, and reputable bibliographic records.
- Documented living traditions: temple, community, and lineage practices, explicitly described as traditions that may vary.
- Secondary explanatory sources: used to clarify context, not to override a primary text.
Text variants and translations
Devotional works often circulate in multiple scripts, spellings, verse orders, and sung versions. We identify meaningful variants when they affect the reader’s understanding, and record each one with the edition that carries it. English meanings are explanatory translations, not replacements for the source language or claims of a single final interpretation.
Citation rules
- Cornerstone pages link directly to the references used.
- Vedic material includes a precise hymn or verse location where available.
- Historical authorship is attributed cautiously and uncertainty is disclosed.
- Search snippets, anonymous posts, and AI-generated answers are not treated as sufficient evidence on their own.
- A broken or changed source link is replaced without silently changing the underlying claim.
- Every citation names a record in the shared source registry.
Public verification manifest
The machine-readable content verification manifest lists every page currently carrying a verification label, the responsible publisher, method, source URLs and source records, last-verified date, and expert-review status. The manifest is generated from the same records used on the visible pages so the two cannot drift silently.
Frequently used reference collections
- Sanskrit Documents for public text comparison and variant discovery.
- Rigveda Online for hymn and verse identification.
- University, government cultural, publisher, and library records for bibliographic or historical claims.
Editorial policy · Source standards · Verification manifest · Corrections